Posted by: Hannah | 11/19/2014

in which People magazine finally gets it (partly) right

It’s that time again! My annual public descent into totally objectifying men in a way that is completely contrary to all feminist principles. I’m afraid that some of the younger women who follow me on Twitter are going to be a little disappointed in me today.

In case you really want to be horrified by what a terrible person I am, here are links to my previous posts:

2013, part one  and 2013, part two

2012, part one and 2012, part two


But look at this!


My imaginary boyfriend of many years – goodness, have I been faithful to my Hemsworth – finally made the cover. And as a bonus, Idris Elba and Chris Pratt are there, too!

Well done, People magazine. You have finally redeemed yourself after last year’s Adam Levine debacle. I still don’t understand that. If looking at a guy immediately makes me think of Axe body spray and roofies, it’s the wrong choice. Ick.

As per usual, there are several different lists inside the actual magazine, including “The History of Sexy”, “Sexiest Best Friends in Hollywood”, “Sexiest Guys Still Up For Grabs” (ew, that’s just gross, even I think so) and “12 Sexy Guys and their Pets”. I’m not going to review any of those lists, sticking only to the main list of twelve.

I’m sorry to say, once you get past the truly stellar cover, things go downhill fast. Once again I am left feeling old and out of touch. Also a little annoyed.

This year, I’ll offer my comments on each of the top twelve, and then I’ll suggest an alternative that should have been there instead, using my own completely-subjective taste to make my selections.

Without further ado, here we go! (Oh, this is always such fun. I’m probably a really shallow person.)

Number One – Chris Hemsworth


Okay, seriously. Blond beefcake with piercing blue eyes is, apparently, not some people’s ‘type’. Whatever, haters. MORE FOR ME, THEN.

It’s not entirely physical though (no, it’s not, shut up). By all accounts, Chris Hemsworth is just a flat-out nice guy. He works hard. Even looking the way he does, he had to put a lot of effort into getting his career off the ground. According to People, he babysat between modelling and acting gigs to help pay the bills. See! We are the same!

He’s married to an older woman. They have three young children and just look at this picture because really, this is sexy.


Add to that all the dreamy hunkiness and, well, anyone who is a friend of mine knows my feelings about The Hems. Michael knows. The kids know. If Chris Hemsworth ever knocks on my door I will disappear for at least 24 hours.

Suggested alternative – None. Are you kidding? Ppfffbbbtt.


Number two – Idris Elba

Now, here’s a weird thing – he’s on the cover, but in the list of eleven men he is not featured. That’s weird. I call bullshit on that and include him as number two, because I’ve been lobbying for Idris Elba for years.

You know what’s awesome? That it’s not Denzel Washington again.

Anyway! Idris Elba.


He’s a very talented actor, he wears the hell out of beautifully-tailored suits, his Twitter feed is often very funny, and his voice is all smoky and smooth. There’s been talk of making him the next James Bond, which I heartily approve of. I’ve been a fan since the early days of The Wire, so it’s nice to see him getting some recognition. Does it make me a hipster that I liked Idris Elba before it was cool? I’m going to say yes.

Suggested alternative – Nope. You can’t improve on perfection, guys.


Number three – Chris Pratt

Oh, Chris Pratt. How adorable is he? Answer: pretty gosh-darned adorable.


He was on Parks & Recreation, where he did not look like that ripped specimen up there, but his sense of humour won me over, because I love scruffily-bearded men who can laugh at themselves. Then he went to the gym and good heavens. As Star-Lord, not only was he sexy, he also convinced us all that it was entirely possible to save the universe with a dance-off and the power of friendship.

Side bonus for me: Michael actually resembles Chris Pratt. He gets embarrassed when I say that, but it’s true. And since my husband is actually my sexiest man, this whole Chris Pratt thing is kind of a no-brainer.



Chris Pratt is also a family man, thus confirming my suspicions that People magazine took a lot of heat last year for crowning a sleazy douchebag who said gross skeezy things about women, and are now trying to make up for it by going as wholesome as one can while composing this kind of list.

Suggested alternative – Again, nope. This is a solid choice and I wouldn’t change it.


Number four – Jamie Dornan


Apparently this guy is playing Christian Grey in the I-know-it-will-be-execrable 50 Shades of Grey movie. I suppose this is why he’s on here – millions of women persist in thinking that Christian Grey is a hot awesome sexy catch of a man instead of a creepy stalking abusive asshole, which makes me despair for humanity.

His one eye is noticeably smaller than the other, or else he’s trying to squint sexily, but either way, nope. His IMDB profile says he was born in Northern Ireland, so if every year’s list needs a scruffy Irishman, may I say…

Suggested alternative – Gabriel Byrne


He’s a fantastic actor, he’s obviously smart, we all loved his convincing turn as Professor Bhaer in 1994’s Little Women – after all, he had to make it plausible that Jo would toss aside Christian Bale’s Laurie for him! He’s got the little half-smile down, he’s a stylish dresser, and ‘soulful’ is not too strong a word for his gaze.


Number five – Ki Hong Lee


This young gentleman just looks confused to me. He’s like a Korean Justin Bieber. The only quote People could get from him was about how dimples are “nature’s mistake” caused by “flawed muscles”, which is odd. He’s got really nice skin, but other than that he looks about sixteen (he’s actually 28), he’s promoting a movie called The Maze Runner which gives me claustrophobic fits every time I see the trailer, and he’s just doing nothing for me at all.

Suggested alternative – John Cho


Unashamed confession time. I loved Harold and Kumar go to White Castle. It was an over-the-top funny movie with a bedrock of clever satire and I have cheerfully re-watched many times over the years. He was also a fun choice to play Sulu in the new Star Trek reboots, and he’s got a nice self-deprecating quality.

I assume People didn’t pick him because of his stoner-comedy past. That kind of pedigree probably doesn’t play well in the heartland of America.

Number six – Blake Shelton


I watched The Voice briefly one winter, and I actually liked Blake Shelton – his voice is a pleasing country-boy drawl, he gives actual good advice to the contestants, he seemed to be taking the process seriously but not assuming anything he was doing was life-changing. I followed him on Twitter and the bloom quickly fell off that rose. He’s awful. He makes sexist, stupid jokes. He drinks to excess and then laughs about what a gaping asshole he is while he’s drunk. He has terrible grammar. So while he may be one of the only straight men on earth who can successfully wear a vest, he’s not sexy (and this entry even features a callback to Adam Levine, so it’s doubly-gross. Again with the Axe body spray smell.)

Suggested alternative – Corb Lund


I know People doesn’t generally cross the Canada / US border looking for faces, but if you need a country-boy type I propose that Corb Lund is a far superior model to Blake Shelton. (Reason # 1 – he’s actually a country boy, as opposed to being a vest-wearing pretender). He’s got great hair. His voice is pleasing to the ear. He seems like a good guy.


Number seven – Bradley Cooper


Not this guy again. I’ve run out of ways to say that Bradley Cooper is just too Bradley Cooper for my tastes. I’m going to leave it up to Danny Castellano to sum up my feelings on Bradley Cooper:


I just don’t get it.

Alternative suggestion – Chris Messina

See, this segues nicely into a character I’ve lately developed a gigantic crush on – Chris Messina’s Danny Castellano from my new favourite show The Mindy Project.


The show’s creator, Mindy Kaling, freely admits that she has a huge crush on Chris Messina herself, and honestly? You have a job where you get to write him as your dream boyfriend who says wonderful things and wears adorable red magnetic reading glasses and decorates gingerbread houses and is the best at making out, ever? That’s the best job anyone has ever had.


Number eight – Matt Bomer


On some level I am a twelve year old boy, because every time I see “Matt Bomer” what I hear in my head is “Matt Boner” and then I laugh and laugh.

He’s mostly famous for co-starring in Magic Mike, a better-than-it-should-have-been movie about male strippers that is getting a completely unnecessary sequel.

He’s attractive enough, I suppose, although he doesn’t look very robust. Seems like he would have a hard time shoveling the driveway, carrying in the groceries, or dealing with my increasingly-insane moods every 28 days or so.

Suggested alternative – Mark Whalberg

The list needs a handsome white guy who can dance in a sexy fashion that makes me feel pants-feelings? Here you go. You’re welcome. The original and still the best, my friends.


Number nine – Michael Strahan



I honestly have no idea who this guy is. *runs to google* Oh. Indeed. He’s a former football player, he’s got an unsightly gap between his front teeth, he’s allegedly got a history of infidelity and he co-stars with Kelly Ripa on that morning talk show that won’t die.

Suggested alternative – Anderson Cooper


So he’s not a former football player but he does have a talk show, and he’s even co-hosted with Kelly Ripa before, if memory serves. I know opinions about Anderson are pretty split but I was always kind of a fan, and then I read his memoir Dispatches from the Edge and gained respect for him, too.

Besides, JUST LOOK AT HIM. He’s looking at you. He wants to tell you things. You want to listen.


Number ten – Eddie Redmayne


I couldn’t for the life of me figure out who this was, so I googled, and oh, he played Marius in the big-screen adaptation of Les Miserables. OK, that’s reasonable. He can sing, he’s got an interesting face, he’s not conventionally-handsome – he can stay.

Alternative suggestion – shrug

I suppose I could find another youngish British man to fill this slot, but frankly I’ve been writing this post for one million hours now and man, this is harder than you’d think.


Number eleven – Scott Foley


I’m sorry, what? Are we still going on about the dude from Felicity? You might as well put Jason Priestly up here and be done with it.

He thinks he’s James Dean. He is not James Dean. As my friend Misty would say, he isn’t actually rugged – he just plays rugged on TV.

Alternative suggestion – Tom Selleck


If we’re going to throwback to TV shows long off the air, I’m going all the way back to Magnum P.I., because Tom Selleck was and is a sexy, rugged guy. Remember the 80s? Remember chest hair? I do. It was fun.


Number twelve – Tim Tebow


What. The. Fuck.

First of all, his head is the wrong shape. He looks like what’s running through his head is the word “durrrrrrr”. He uses his football career as a platform to proselytize. He doesn’t know how t-shirts work (why are you pulling down on that shirt, Tim Tebow?) I’m sure there are a whole lot of grandmas who think he’s a nice young man with good values, but I just find him completely bland, boring, and unappealing.

Suggested alternative – Adam van Koeverden

images (1)

Again I must thank Misty for this suggestion, which is a good one. He’s a world and Olympic champion. He’s a proud Canadian. He works his ass off, he’s smart (was valedictorian of his graduating class at McMaster University!), is apparently a pleasant person and is very easy on the eyes to boot.

People magazine, I suggest that you might consider looking north occasionally. I think you could sell this guy, I really do.


Whew. That was exhausting (and it was only one list). I always feel kind of guilty after spending a day on this, and then this article from Slate was pointed out to me – now I feel like an even bigger skeeze because I’m buying into the whole mess.

It’s fun though, too. I feel the way I do after I eat a whole bag of chips – satisfied, but the satisfaction is tinged with regret.



  1. Well this old lady loves your list and I agree with all your choices. Especially Adam Van Koerverden!! Delightful reading indeed.

    • *high fives*

  2. I’m always fascinated by your annual round-up of sexy men, because I have never heard of any of them, on your list or on People’s, and don’t find a single one remotely attractive (that’s no surprise though; I’m not wired right for that). I do agree, however, that Michael bears a resemblance to his celebrity counterpart.

    • I had to google a few of them this year because I just had no idea who they are, if that makes you feel any better. 🙂

  3. Sadly, the celebrity I actually resemble is Steven Page. Formerly of the Bare Naked Ladies. He is former because of his cocaine fuelled public crash and burn. And pudgy. I suppose I may slightly resemble Chris Pratt in his pudgy parks & rec persona. Maybe. If you squint. 🙂 A lot.
    Otherwise, fair list.

    • Sweetie, you are SO MUCH better-looking than Steven Page, truly. ❤

      • SO MUCH better-looking. AND less of a douche. I mean, love his voice, seriously, forever. But he’s a douche.

  4. WOOO!! I got a mention. I’m FAMOUS. I also like Adam very much.

    • I’m glad we had that chat this morning because it really did help fill in some holes in my post. So thank you. 🙂

  5. Gabriel Byrne is my FAVOURITE as you know, and Marky Mark. Sigh. Matt Boner, hee, that’s what I think of too.

    You know…neither Chrises Hemsworth nor Pratt are the types that I typically am attracted to – but I can definitely appreciate them as physical specimens. You can have my share! Aren’t I a good friend?

    • You’re the best friend! In return, I will offer you my share of Jim Cuddy.

  6. Thank you! Thank you! Finally somebody else is rooting for my Corb Lund. And yes, he is my Corb Lund. Him and I have an imaginary ranch somewhere in Alberta.

    • When The Hemsworth & I get married, we’ll come visit you at your imaginary ranch.

  7. If we had known each other during our younger, single days we could have gone to the bar and never fought over boys. Our tastes are totally different. Except for Idris. Every lady loves him.

    So the big reveal of Hemsworth winning happened last night after nearly everyone in my twitter feed had logged off. Hence my poor husband had to sit and listen to me rant about Tim Tebow for a good 20 minutes. I should’ve just written this earlier:

    • Time zones are dumb. And yes, I heartily agree with your Tim Tebow assessment. Just… No.

  8. I agree with everything except the Matt Bomer exchange. He is unnaturally good looking. I mean even by Hollywood standards. He’s pretty as hell. Not rugged. No. But good looking. Anyway the exchange for him for MW doesn’t work for me because MW has a history of being kind of a racist asshole. I believe he’s apologized and whatnot but I have trouble forgetting about that so he’s off the list for me.

    • I don’t know why Matt Bomer doesn’t do it for me – objectively I can see that he is very pretty – but he just doesn’t. It’s weird.

      • Bomer is quite good-looking. I don’t think he could stand up to me. He is pretty, though….kindof like Sommerhalder. Both are of the same type: dark hair, light skin, light eyes. That Spanish influenced Irish look….mmmmm.

  9. Completely agree all around – I do not get these people (NICOLE) who claim that Hemsworth does nothing for them. Are they dead inside?

    Also: I adore me some John Cho. Fab choice!

  10. I still say Neil deGrasse Tyson should have been on the list.

    Thor sure is pretty, though and better yet he seems like a lovely chap.

    I am really not a fan of celebrity gossip magazines and stuff.

    You make this seem an honourable mission!

    Great job! Love John Cho. He and Matthew Perry make a great team!

  11. Keep in mind that People populates this list with individuals who are willing to submit to their interviewing…which is why the original choice from last year, Ryan Gosling, didn’t end up in the top spot and Adam Levine did. One person’s management team went “Yeah, no, we don’t need that, it doesn’t fit our strategy”, and the other’s went “PUBLICITY, WHOOT!”. Honestly, that’s the long and the short of it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: